Can we talk about how it’s been, what, 4? 5 years? since Castiel took over Jimmy’s body permanently.
That’s how long it has been since Claire lost her daddy. How old is she now? Late teens? Early twenties? She could be around your age right now and she is living her live without her father.
What if, one day, maybe during school trip, maybe she works parttime somewhere, and she catches the sight of a familiar trenchcoat? What if she hears the rumble of a car passing by and see a glimpse of a face that has been haunting her dreams every other night? What if her eyes meet with a pair of blue eyes, familiar but at the same time so unfamiliar?
Maybe she’ll stop herself from calling ‘Daddy’, because that’s not her daddy.
Maybe she’ll will her foot not to chase the black car, because that’s not her daddy.
Maybe she’ll close her eyes and look the other way, because she knows that’s not her daddy.
Because Claire knows, since the angel left her body years ago, since he walked away from that hunter saying he served Heaven, she knows that she won’t see her daddy ever again.